John's Pizza & Subs Menu (2025 Update)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Introducing John's Pizza & Subs, a local gem nestled in Tonawanda Town, NY, known for its mouthwatering subs and pizzas. This establishment prides itself on a diverse menu that caters to every craving. From the Baked Cheese Sub, a delightful blend of five cheeses, to the hearty Italian Sausage Sub and the crispy Fish Sub, there's something for everyone at their reasonable prices.

  • Pizza Varieties: Their signature Pizza Sauce topped with fresh mozzarella offers the perfect base for customizing with your favorite toppings.
  • Wrap Platters: Perfect for parties, featuring favorites like the Buffalo Wrap and assorted options to please any crowd.

Customers rave about the consistently fresh ingredients, particularly in their beloved turkey clubs and subs, making John's Pizza & Subs a must-visit for both locals and travelers.

Beverages Pizza - Hot & Fresh Everyday! Gourmet Pizzas Hot Subs Mix & Match Pizza Specials A La Carte Cold Cut Sub Sub Platter Pizza Wing Combos Chicken Wings & Boneless Wings Something Different Chicken Fingers Salads Specialty Subs Wrap Platter Tacos & Wraps

Beverages

Bottled Water

Bottled Water
US$3.08

20 Oz. Bottle

Choose from Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Starry
US$3.42

2 Liter Bottle

Your choice of flavors
US$4.09

Small Cheese Pizza (6 Pieces)

10" Pizza cut in to 6 slices
US$11.30

Medium Cheese Pizza (8 Pieces)

13" Pizza cut in to 8 Slices
US$16.68

Slice Of Pizza

Start with a Slice of Cheese and add any toppings you want
US$3.86

Party Tray Cheese Pizza (30 Squares)

Two 1/2 Tray Pizzas for 30 Slices in total
US$37.02

Half Tray Cheese Pizza (15 Squares)

1/2 Tray Pizza cut in to 15 squares
US$22.50

Large Cheese Pizza (10 Pieces)

Large 16" Pie cut in to 10 Slices
US$22.50

Heart Shaped Pizza

Valentines Day Mothers Day, Birthdays or just to say you Love Them
US$22.50

Pizza - Hot & Fresh Everyday!

Gourmet Pizzas

White Pizza

Shredded Parmesan, Romano and Mozzarella cheeses over a blend of garlic and olive oil, topped with diced tomato and fresh onion.
US$16.68

Spinach & Tomato Pizza

Our pizza crust topped with garlic and olive oil then covered in a blend or Romano, Parmesan, and mozzarella cheese and fresh spinach and tomato.
US$16.68

John’s Big Mac

(Buffalo pizza fest award winner) Fresh hamburger, thousand island dressing, pickles, chopped onions a blend of Mozzarella, American and Swiss cheeses then topped with lettuce.
US$16.68

Extra Blue Cheese

Blue Cheese for dipping of course...
US$2.30

Meat Eaters Supreme

Our Cheese Pizza Topped with Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Bacon & Ham
US$16.68

Nashville Hot Chicken

Hot & Crispy Boneless Chicken Wings on top of Ranch Dressing with Dill Pickles covered in Mozzarella & Cheddar Cheeses and Drizzled with Sweet Baby Ray’s Honey Hot Sauce!
US$16.68

The Original Chicken Finger Pizza

Tender Tyson Chicken Fingers, creamy blue cheese, celery, hot sauce, and mozzarella.
US$16.68

3 Cheese Steak Pizza

Ribeye steak, fresh mushrooms, onions, your choice of hot, banana or green peppers, a blend of Mozzarella, Swiss, American cheese baked in our pizza dough covered in our very own garlic sauce.
US$16.68

Stinger Pizza

Creamy blue cheese topped with tyson chicken fingers grilled rib eye steak franks hot sauce and then covered in Mozzarella & Povolone.
US$17.86

Taco Pizza

Our Fresh Baked Pizza Crust topped with Salsa, Fresh Taco Meat,Cheddar Cheese, Black Olives then Baked to perfection and topped with Lettuce & Tomato
US$16.68

Cheeseburger Sub

Juicy Burgers with Lettuce, Tomato and your choice of condiments.
US$10.25

Baked Cheese

A 5 Cheese Favorite Baked to perfection with Lettuce & Tomato.
US$8.90

Chicken Philly

Lettuce, Tomato & Cheese
US$9.13

Royal Sub

Italian Sausage, Capicola, Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese
US$10.25

Pizza Sub

Our Signature Pizza Sauce with Mozzarella Cheese. Add your favorite topping
US$8.90

Steak & Cheese

Tender Rib Eye Steak, Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato
US$10.25

Ultimate Vegetable

Not a Meat Eater? This Sub comes with Lettuce, Tomato, Green Peppers, Black Olives & Mushrooms topped with Mozzarella Cheese then Baked to Perfection.
US$8.90

Italian Sausage

Mild Italian Sausage with Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese.
US$9.13

Fish Sub

Delicious Deep Fried Cod, Tarter Sauce, Lettuce, Tomato and Yellow American Cheese.
US$10.25

Fried Bologna & Onion

An Old Favorite, Fried Bologna & Onions with Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese.
US$8.90

Hot Subs

Mix & Match Pizza Specials

Mix & Match 2 Small Pizzas

One Small Cheese Pizza and One Small Gourmet Pizza of Your Choice
US$28.21

Mix & Match 2 Medium Pizzas

One Medium Cheese Pizza & One Medium Gourmet Pizza of Your Choice
US$42.95

Mix & Match 2 Large Or 1/2 Tray Pizzas

One Large or 1/2 Tray Cheese Pizza and One Large or 1/2 Tray Gourmet Pizza of Your Choice
US$58.86

Flavored Curly Q’s

Special seasoned Curly Q's
US$5.10

French Fries

Something to share...or keep all to yourself
US$4.80

BBQ Pizza Logs (4)

We Caramelized BBQ Sauce on our Pizza Logs. You Have To Try These!! Add a Blue Cheese for Dipping
US$11.14

Cheesy Garlic Bread Sticks

Served with a side of marinara.
US$5.21

Hot Poppers

Cheddar Jalapeno bites with a side of Ranch Dressing
US$10.14

Onion Rings

Beer Battered Onion Rings cooked to a Golden Brown
US$6.55

Buffalo Bread

Our garlic bread topped with diced chicken finger tossed in hot sauce with blue cheese and melted mozzarella.
US$13.27

Brownie

Chocolate Brownie (Gluten Free)
US$4.20

Fried Pickle Chips

Served with Ranch Dressing
US$8.39

Funnel Cake Fries

Your favorite carnival treat...bite size. With cinnamon and powdered sugar
US$6.04

Mozzarella Sticks (5)

5 Gooey Mozzarella Sticks with a side of Marinara
US$9.13

Chips
US$2.41

Pizza Logs (4)

4 Pizza Logs with a side of Marinara
US$10.25

Chocolate Chip Cookie
US$2.52

Sampler Platter

You Pick 4 Items, Pizza Logs (3), Mozzarella Sticks (3), Hot Poppers (5), Small Cheesy Bread Sticks, Chicken Fingers (3) Specify Hot, Medium, Mild or Plain, Onion Rings (5) or French Fries.
US$23.51

A La Carte

Cold Cut Sub

Turkey Club Sub

Our Oven Roasted Turkey Topped with Bacon, Lettuce Tomato & Provolone Cheese.
US$11.64

Ham Sub

Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese.
US$9.58

Turkey Sub

Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese.
US$9.80

The BLT Sub

Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese.
US$10.40

Tuna Sub

Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese.
US$9.80

Roast Beef Sub

Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese.
US$10.40

The Hercules

Thinly sliced Ham & Turkey piled high on your choice of sub roll.
US$10.29

Salami Sub

Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese.
US$9.58

Assorted Sub

Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese.
US$9.58

Capicola Sub

Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese.
US$9.58

John's Chicken Finger Sub Platter (New)

5 of our famous chicken finger subs served with a hot sauce to your liking kraft blue cheese, lettuce & tomato and a side of hot & banana peppers.
US$80.29

Cold Cut Platter

Roast beef, ham, turkey, assorted, hercules (ham and turkey).
US$73.80

John’s Original Sub Platter

Three oven roasted turkey subs & two ham and cheese subs.
US$75.36

Sub Platter

Pizza Wing Combos

Large Or 1/2 Tray Pizza With Your Choice Of 20 Wings, 20 Boneless Wings Or 12 Chicken Fingers

Large (round 10 slice) or 1/2 tray (15 squares) pizza with 20 wings, 20 Boneless Wings or 12 Chicken Fingers
US$52.81

Small Pizza With Your Choice Of 5 Wings Or 5 Boneless Wings

Small Pizza with your choice of 5 Wings or 5 Boneless Wings .Not Included (Celery, Carrots or Blue Cheese) Blue Cheese may be added in modifier group.
US$21.00

Party Tray Pizza & 50 Wings

Party Pizza ( 30 Squares) with 50 Wings.
US$106.38

Medium Pizza With Your Choice Of 10 Wings, 10 Boneless Wings Or 7 Chicken Fingers

Medium Pizza (8 slices) with your choice of 10 Wings, 10 Boneless Wings or 7 Chicken Fingers
US$34.82

Party Tray Gourmet Pizza With Your Choice Of 30 Wings, 30 Boneless Wings Or 20 Chicken Fingers

Party Tray Gourmet Pizza with your choice of 30 Wings, 30 Boneless Wings or 20 Chicken Fingers.
US$93.58

Medium Gourmet Pizza & 10 Wings, 10 Boneless Wings Or 7 Chicken Fingers

A Medium Gourmet Pizza with your choice of 10 Wings, !0 Boneless Wings or 7 Chicken Fingers
US$38.40

Party Tray Pizza & 50 Boneless Wings Or 30 Chicken Fingers

Party Tray Pizza (30 squares) with your choice of 50 Boneless Wings or 30 Chicken Fingers
US$92.12

Large Or 1/2 Tray Gourmet Pizza With Your Choice Of 20 Wings, Boneless Wings Or 12 Chicken Fingers

A Large (round 10 slice) or 1/2 Tray Gourmet Pizza (15 squares) with your choice of 20 Wings, 20 Boneless Wings or 12 Chicken Fingers.
US$59.68

Party Tray Gourmet Pizza & 50 Wings

Your choice of our Gourmet Pizzas with 50 Wings
US$114.12

Party Tray Gourmet Pizza & 50 Boneless Wings Or 30 Chicken Fingers

Party Tray Gourmet Pizza with your choice of 50 Boneless Wings or 30 Chicken Fingers.
US$100.74

Party Tray Pizza & Your Choice Of 30 Wings, 30 Boneless Wings Or 20 Chicken Fingers

Party Tray Pizza (30 slices) with your choice of 30 chicken wings, 30 Boneless wings or 20 Chicken Fingers
US$81.59

Chicken Wings Snack (5)

5 Chicken Wings with your choice of Sauce. Not Included (Celery, Carrots & Blue Cheese) Those must be added per Customer Request
US$10.52

Extra Blue Cheese

Side of Blue Cheese
US$2.30

Chicken Wings Single (10)

Served with Celery, Carrots & Blue Cheese.
US$18.58

Boneless Wings Double (20)

Served with Celery, Carrots & 2 Blue Cheese.
US$29.96

Boneless Wings Triple (30)

Served with Celery, Carrots & 2 Blue Cheese.
US$41.43

Boneless Wings Single (10)

Served with Celery, Carrots & Blue Cheese.
US$17.35

Chicken Wings Double (20)

Served with Celery, Carrots & 2 Blue Cheese.
US$34.66

Boneless Wings Bucket (50)

Served with Celery, Carrots & 3 Blue Cheese.
US$64.95

Chicken Wings Triple (30)

Served with Celery, Carrots & 2 Blue Cheese.
US$46.24

Chicken Wings Bucket (50)

Served with Celery, Carrots & 3 Blue Cheese.
US$69.94

Chicken Wings & Boneless Wings

Something Different

Fish Fry

Beer battered haddock with cole slaw, French fries and garlic bread.
US$20.55

Beef On Weck

Over a quarter pound of thinly sliced beef served on a toasted kummelweck roll with french fries horse radish & pickle.
US$13.43

Individual Finger

1 Single Chicken Finger
US$3.53

Extra Blue Cheese

Blue cheese for dipping of course...
US$2.30

30 Chicken Fingers

30 Huge Chicken Fingers shaken in your choice of sauce
US$68.53

20 Chicken Fingers

20 Chicken Fingers. Split them up however you want
US$45.64

Large Chicken Finger Dinner

10 Chicken Fingers served with Fries, Celery, Carrots & 2 Blue Cheese. Please Specify Sauce Choice.
US$30.23

Small Chicken Finger Dinner

5 Chicken Fingers served with Fries, Celery, Carrots & Blue Cheese. Please Specify Sauce Choice.
US$18.24

Chicken Fingers

Salads

Julienne Salad

A fresh bed of salad greens and tomato, topped with turkey, ham, Cheddar and Monterrey Jack cheese then garnished with cucumber slices and hard boiled eggs.
US$7.56

Antipasto

A mixture of peppers, cheese, cold cuts, olives, onions, and fresh salad green. It's a meal in itself!!!
US$9.46

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Fresh Salad Greens, Tender Chicken Fingers tossed in Frank's Hot Sauce & Monterrey Jack Cheese
US$8.68

Beef Taco Salad

A Crisp Tortilla Shell filled with Taco Meat, Shredded Lettuce, Diced Tomato, Shredded Cheddar Cheese, Black Olives, Hot or Banana Peppers and served with Salsa & Sour Cream on the side.
US$13.20

Chicken Taco Salad

A crisp floured shell filled with lettuce, tomatoes, black olives, hot or sweet peppers, Cheddar and Monterrey Jack cheese, topped with char-broiled chicken, served with salsa and sour cream.
US$13.20

Greek Salad

Fresh crisp salad green with chicken or steak topped with green and black olives, Feta cheese, sweet peppers, egg, cucumber and tomato, served with a side of greek salad dressing!
US$9.24

Chef Salad

Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber with a side of Dressing
US$5.70

Apple Almond Grilled Chicken Salad

A crisp blend of salad greens, dice apples, Feta cheese, roasted almonds, crasins, tomatoes, cucumbers topped with tender strips of grilled chicken tenderloin.
US$7.83

The Godfather

Thinly sliced ham and capicola piled high, baked with pepperoni and Provolone cheese then topped with lettuce and tomato.
US$11.93

Chicken In The Grass

Grilled chicken, fresh spinach, your choice of dressing, baked with Provolone cheese then topped with lettuce and tomato.
US$13.16

The Nightmare

Rib eye steak, Italian sausage, lettuce, tomato and cheese.
US$13.50

Steak-N-Ring

Our delicious steak and cheese sub topped with golden brown onion rings and smothered with Mozzarella cheese, Lettuce & Tomato.
US$13.09

Sweet Chili Chicken Finger Sub

With Franks Sweet Chili Sauce, Kraft Blue Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato & Provolone Cheese
US$12.82

Steak Hoagie

Loaded with tender rib eye steak, sauteed onions, mushrooms and your choice of hot, sweet or green peppers then topped with melted cheese. Please specify your choice of peppers.
US$12.53

John’s Italian Delight

Our version of a sausage Parmesan in our original sauce and topped off with Mozzarella then baked.
US$9.91

Meatball Parmesan

Plump meatballs in our spaghetti sauce covered with loads of Mozzarella then baked.
US$9.91

Stinger

A mouthful of juicy rib eye steak and tender chicken fingers, cheese, lettuce and tomato. Please specify Hot, Medium or Mild with or without Blue Cheese or Mayo
US$13.50

Western Chicken Finger Sub

Made with plump juicy chicken fingers, smothered with our delicious bbq sauce, topped with American cheese. All served on a toasted roll with lettuce, tomato and mayo.
US$12.82

Steak In The Grass

Chopped rib eye steak, fresh spinach, lettuce, tomato, and Provolone cheese topped with your choice of dressing and baked to perfection.
US$13.16

Original Chicken Finger Sub

It's now an institution, our famous chicken fingers shaken in our tangy hot sauce with lettuce, tomato, Provolone cheese, then smothered with Bleu cheese. Copied the world over yet still the original and the best....since 1982! Please specify Hot, Medium or Mild with or without blue cheese.
US$12.82

Italian Sausage Hoagie

An American favorite: Italian sausage, fried onions and mushrooms and your choice of Hot Peppers, Banana Peppers or Green Peppers (Please Specify) then topped with Mozzarella cheese and baked to perfection.
US$12.53

Chicken Hoagie

Grilled chicken tenderloin, sauteed onion, mushroom and your choice of hot, green or banana peppers then topped with Mozzarella cheese and baked to perfection. Please specify your choice of peppers.
US$12.53

Chicken Parmesan Sub

Our breaded chicken fingers with spaghetti sauce then covered in melted Sorrento Mozzarella.
US$12.31

Specialty Subs

Wrap Platter

Buffalo Wrap Platter

Six original buffalo chicken wraps with hot sauce, blue cheese, lettuce tomato, and provolone cheese. Four Western wraps with barbecue sauce, mayo, lettuce, tomato, and American cheese.
US$88.24

Assorted Wrap Platter

Three Turkey Wraps, Three Ham & Cheese Wraps, Two Greek Wraps with Chicken, Two Grilled Chicken Wraps.
US$84.39

Chicken Wrap

Grilled chicken tenderloin with lettuce, tomato and cheese served hot, medium or mild.
US$10.29

Fish Taco

Battered Cod Filet on your choice of Wheat or White Tortilla with American Cheese, Tarter, Lettuce & Tomato.
US$10.14

Stinger Wrap

Chopped rib eye steak, chicken fingers, lettuce, tomato & cheese, choice of dressing.
US$14.39

Buffalo Wrap

Crispy Fingers Shaken in our Tangy Hot Sauce, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheese and Your Choice of Dressing.
US$11.52

Greek Wrap

Grilled Chicken or Rib-Eye Steak with Lettuce, Tomato, Feta Cheese, Banana Peppers & Black Olives with Greek Dressing.
US$11.52

Beef Taco

Fresh ground beef, cheese, lettuce & tomato served hot, medium or mild
US$9.96

Tacos & Wraps